I have tried to make my own little mark in this world. My career as a Medical Educator and Clinician in Gastroenterology (see www.gastroindia.net) and my flirtations with Health Promotion, especially amongst school children (see www.hope.org.in) are shown elsewhere.This blog contains my attempts at creative writing, most being write-ups for Health Adda column of HT City of Hindustan Times (also see www.healthaddaindia.blogspot.com) as well as a few others, and some reflections and thoughts that have struck me from time to time on my life journey.Please leave your footprint on this blog with your comment.


Sunday, December 22, 2013

Warning about drug side-effects often help create them


Funny as it might seem, patients who are warned too much of possible side-effects before being given a medication, seem to experience them more often. Describing this phenomenon as the NOCEBO effect, German researcher Winfried Hauser has recently shown that patients anticipating side-effects such as giddiness, headache, constipation or lack of concentration, experience them more often than those who take the drug without being told about them.

This new finding fits well with what physicians have suspected all along, that the body’s response to therapy often depends on the patient’s belief with which he takes it. Some of the benefits of medicine undoubtedly come from the positive anticipation that a particular drug will work as intended -- easing arthritis or relieving wheezing, for example – called the PLACEBO effect. On the flip side our belief in a drug’s side effects may actually cause us to suffer from them as well.

The role of suggestion and belief in obtaining a positive response from treatment is well known. Scientists have shown that PLACEBO medication, that is one which has no active ingredient but looks like a drug, such as an empty capsule, often produces remarkable benefit when taken with positive anticipation of relief.  As many as 50% of patients report benefit in headaches, abdominal pain, dyspepsia and sexual functions with dummy medicines consumed in good faith.

Dr Winfried, an expert in psychosomatic medicine, who has visited India two times, feels that imagination and fears of patients can have just the opposite effect. When cautioned that a drug may cause sexual dysfunction, for example, a larger number of patients taking it report experiencing it.

A lady who consulted me with the history of breaking into allergic hives on taking virtually every antibiotic had a similar reaction when administered a vitamin capsule that looked like an antibiotic. Her hives disappeared when she was told and assured that it was a vitamin and not an antibiotic.

Practitioners of alternative and indigenous systems of medicine bank more on faith and do not usually mention side-effects of their therapy. Patients too therefore consider these innocuous and harmless, and consequently do not report side effects with their use.

Is keeping patients in the dark about a drug’s potential side effects, then the only solution?  In modern times it would be clearly not ethical. What experts propose is “contextualized informed consent,” that takes into account the possible side effects, the patient being treated, and the disease involved. While it will be clearly important to caution against potentially dangerous side effects, such as drowsiness while prescribing anti-allergic drugs to a person who might drive a car for instance, mentioning lack of concentration with an anti-diarrheal to an exam-going student may cause unnecessary harm.

While modern medicine requires that all potential effects of therapy, beneficial as well as harmful, be placed on the table, which aspects to highlight and which ones to downplay remains a matter of the wise doctor’s discretion.

As published in HT City ( Hindustan Times) dated 19th August, 2012.

Cancer Takes the Final Bow

The ovation that has marked Yuvraj Singh’s recent return to the cricket field has much more to do with just a cricketer’s homecoming to the lime-lit pitch. It has come to symbolize human triumph over a disease that has till now been considered invariably fatal.

Yuvi’s rendezvoux with the rare germ-cell cancer, starting from its delayed diagnosis, his hesitation to confront it and start treatment, the bewildering experience of seeing his bald head in the mirror, his anguish of having to sit away while his team played on the field have made his cancer a touching human story for the public. And, in our all too familiar Bollywood style of “All’s well that ends well”, his return to the cricket field with hair on his head gives us the deja vu feeling at the climax when the villain is finally bashed up by the hero.

Our perception of cancer has been undergoing considerable change over the last few decades. Rajesh Khanna’s epic movie “Anand” depicted it as a “tragic” illness which ultimately took its toll. Fighting it was not much of an option, and going down gracefully is all that one could do.

Kylie Minogue’s affliction with breast cancer in the last decade rang a similar bell as that of Yuvi’s, and made women both aware and confident of dealing with a disease that has haunted them. This Australian pop singer celebrity’s untimely detection of breast cancer, her long fight with the disease, her candid disclosures of her illness, and her final victory over it heralded by her return to the stage helped convince many that this too was possible.

Five of South American leaders have been diagnosed with cancer. And as is the spirit of our modern times, they are all battling it well and continuing to lead their nations. Fidel Castro, the veteran Cuban leader, was the eldest and most senior one to undergo surgery for his disease. Hugo Chavez, the outspoken Venezuelen president has undergone several surgeries for his cancer and has been probably certified cured. Argentina’s elegant lady leader Christina Fernandez de Kirchner had thyroid cancer, from which she has recovered. Two of Brazil’s leaders, the current president Luiz Inacio Lula de Silva and the past Dilma Rouseff are cancer patients. And in neighboring Paraguay, Fernando Lugo is battling cancer too.

Cancer is no longer a disease that is rare and occurs only to others. It has found its way from remote corners to the backyards and now to our homes. What however has changed in recent times is our spirit – from an easily yielding one in Anand to that of an indomitable and resilient one, fuelled by our resolve to return to the field to play again.

As published in HT City ( Hindustan Times) dated 12th August, 2012.

What Money Cannot Buy

Affluence sometimes serves as a double edged sword, getting you and your loved one access to high quality medical care in 5-starred hospitals, but at times buying you heaps of misery and suffering as well.

Mr Gupta’s 40 year old son, who looks after the family’s thriving businessis unable to come to terms that his father cannot be saved despite any amount that he is ready to spend.

Mr VK Gupta (name changed), 87 had ben diagnosed with liver cirrhosis and has been ailing since then with weakness and swelling of his feet and abdomen. Last month he had slipped into liver coma and respiartory failure. The affluent business family, wanting the best treatment for their father, had air-lifted him to a very modern ICU in a posh tertiary care hospital in the capital for care.

My encounter with the family was during ICU rounds. While an excellent team of doctors took as good care of him at par with the best hospitals of the world, he continued to sink. They monitored his his blood counts, creatinine, electrolytes, albumin, ventilator pararmeters, urine output, pro-calcitonin levels, SOFA scores and so on but he reamined ventilator dependent and unresponsive. An equally excellent team of young nurses performed 290 nursing tasks every day for him – from cleaning his back and airways, checking his IV lines and catheters, ensuring the right kind and amount of tube feed went into his body, provided eye and mouth toilet and an endless list of things that kept him technically alive with his heart still beating although hooked on to machines and tubes. It had cost the family Rs 50,000 every day for a month, but they were prepared to go on as long as required.

During my daily ritual of counseling I learnt that they had spent around Rs 20 lac already.  What was frustration to the family however was that the money was not getting their father anywhere near cure. They were prepared to spend another Rs 50 lac for a liver transplant if only the doctors would try!

They found it difficult to accept that their father was too old to undergo a major surgery at 87, and that how, for the 1st time in this condition was too frail to even give it a try. For the 1st time in their lives, they were confronted with a situation where money in any amount seemed to prove inadequate to solve their problem.

Mr Gupta had started his business 50 years ago that had brought him and the family to prosperity. The thought that they could shying away from any expense his treatment required, filled them with guilt.

While the old man’s soul seemed locked for weeks in an old, frail, diseased body, perhaps aspiring for release, the family’s wealth ensured that his pain was indefinitely prolonged.

I thought of all the poor villagers around Mohanlalganj who came to government hospitals, had much less means but more clarity of thinking to accept the inevitable.

As published in HT City ( Hindustan Times) dated 5th August, 2012.

Local Heroes Show the Way

Mr Pradeep Kumar Srivastava, a common looking man, is no longer a common man. He has climbed roles from a devastated patient of Hepatitis B for 8 years to a hero who has cleared the infection and now to an activist guiding others to prevent and treat this deadly infection. And who can be more convincing than him to tell what it entails being a patient?

The ground under his feet had shaken 8 years ago when he, along with his friends, had gone for a screening blood examination in 2004 and tested positive for Hepatitis B. Although he worked in a laboratory as a technician, he did not remember any accidental exposure to blood or blood products. He had never had jaundice, and had felt perfectly fine till this test had robbed his bliss. In disbelief, he got the test repeated from 3 labs. All were unfortunately positive!

Advice kept pouring freely in. Some wondered how he was still alive, others said that there was no treatment and he was doomed to die, while many suggested going for alternative medicines. He was worried about his wife and small children and wondered how much time he had with them.

He however decided not to give in but to fight back. He took the long crowded road to SGPGI and after 5 hours of wait in the claustrophobic OPD hall, confronted me with the question “ Is it treatable?”

Further tests revealed that his infection was not a mild one; the Hepatitis B virus was actively multiplying in his liver, and the viral load in the blood was in millions. Considearble damage had already occured, and elevated levels of the liver enzymes SGOT and SGPT indicated that liver cells were still dying.

Having understood that the treatment had to be long, he started with oral anti-viral medications. The response was impressive; within 6 months, his liver functions had normalized and the viral load had come down significantly.

He attended our liver clinic with determined regularity. We watched his tests improve with each 6 monthly visit. His envelope antigen, a marker for viral multiplication, turned negative in 3 years, his liver functions improved to normal levels and he started getting the feeling that he may not die soon afterall.

He learnt much about Hepatitis B, attending all our seminars and film shows regularly. Convinced that he was indeed getting better, he joined the HOPE team in our yearly World Hepatitis Day functions on July 28 over the last few years, voluntarily lending his hands in the free screening camps, rallies and road shows.


God was probably watching. This year he greeted me with a grin when his HBsAg, the last marker of infection also turned negative. “Am I now cured for life?” he asked with baited breath. He was honored this year as a champion and a hero who had fought and overcome this infection with grit and perseverance.

As published in HT City ( Hindustan Times) dated 29th July, 2012.